Controversial Angus substation plans refused amid ‘industrial carbuncle’ fears
Plans for an electricity substation to be built in Angus have been refused by councillors amid fears it would be an “industrial carbuncle”.
The application, lodged by SSEN, sought permission to build a substation platform at Balkemback Farm in Tealing.


The proposed location is at the southern end of a line of planned ‘super-pylons’ SSEN wants to run from Aberdeenshire to Angus.
The Scottish Government will decide on the 400kV line scheme. However, a decision on the substation application was in the hands of Angus Council. Under the plans, 22 400/275kV open-air substation bays would have covered an area equivalent of approximately 28 football pitches.
The proposals went before councillors at a special full council meeting on Tuesday.
The plans prompted the largest ever number of objections to an Angus planning application, with the local authority receiving more than 1,700 representations.
During Tuesday’s meeting, a series of emotionally charged deputations objecting to the proposals were heard by councillors.
Among those calling for councillors to oppose the development was Alison Wiseman, whose Balnuith Alpacas business would be yards from the proposed substation.
She said: “I’m here to ask someone to help us to defend our homes, our village and our lifestyle. With my walking track being adjacent to the road and only eight meters from the site entrance, there goes my tranquil stroll (and the) beautiful Angus countryside.”
She added: “And, indeed, my award-winning alpaca business will be all gone.”
Speaker Sandra Ashworth added: “My property would end up being enclosed on two sides by super pylons and face directly on to the proposed substation site.
“This industrial presence, in my view, would cause catastrophic harm to the residential amenity, landscape, character and rural land use.”
However, SSEN representative Russell Stewart argued: “There is an element we are delivering the substation and the wider infrastructure works that are facilitating a move to green energy in the UK, benefitting everyone.
“But we are also looking to make sure there are local benefits that are brought forward into these areas, that actually there is a legacy of jobs, housing, and economic benefit that we leave behind us.”
However, councillors largely opposed the substation proposals.
Speaking at the meeting, Councillor Lloyd Melville said: “Even when pressed, the applicant could not demonstrate tangible economic benefit.
“We don’t get to a fair and inclusive transition by ignoring the views of local communities and ripping up the local environment.
“We get there by working with people and making energy work for communities.”
Councillor Gavin Nicol added that the proposals were at odds with their surroundings
He said: “Coming out of Dundee up the dual carriageway towards Tealing, there is a road sign that says birthplace of Scotland.
“And a few hundred metres up the road, we’re going to be faced with this industrial carbuncle.
“This project does not benefit anyone in the area and also ruins the rural setting.”
The plans were subsequently rejected, with 19 councillors voting against the proposals and two in favour.
The substation decision comes after Angus councillors unanimously decided to oppose the multi-million-pound overhead line scheme last month.
Statutory consultees, such as councils, were given two months to give their responses to the application.
The Scottish Government will ultimately decide on the application. However, the local authority’s opposition could spark a public inquiry.